In his 34 years as Chief Justice of the Supreme Court (1801–1835), John Marshall transformed the weakest branch of the federal government into a pillar of the nation. Courtmaker tells his story through a collection of defining moments that illuminate his life, his principles, and his enduring influence on American law.
Forming a More Perfect Union
From the battlefields of Valley Forge to the halls of the Virginia Legislature, Marshall’s early service as a soldier, diplomat, and statesman laid the foundation for his leadership on the Court. Rare archival images and expert interviews trace how these experiences forged the man who would steer the Supreme Court into national prominence.
Expounding a Superior Law
In cases like Marbury v. Madison, McCulloch v. Maryland, and the treason trial of Aaron Burr, Marshall asserted that neither the executive or legislative branch could override the constitution and the court’s role in enforcing it. Courtroom recreations in Marshall’s own 4th Virginia Circuit bring these historic moments to life.
Promoting the General Welfare
Through Gibbons v. Ogden and Dartmouth College v. Woodward, Marshall strengthened America’s commercial foundation, protecting contracts and interstate commerce from political interference. Present-day voices reveal how his vision still fuels the nation’s economic engine.
Liberty, Tranquility, and the Limits of Judicial Power
In decisions like the Antelope case and Worcester v. Georgia, Marshall confronted the nation’s deepest moral and political divides. The film explores the limits of judicial authority when presidents refuse to enforce rulings, and invites viewers to consider how Marshall might have ruled in cases that came after his time, including Dred Scott.
From starting as the young captain at Valley Forge to becoming the nation’s most influential jurist, Courtmaker revisits historic trials in Marshall’s own courtroom, captures his politically disarming charm, and features voices ranging from legal scholars to U.S. Supreme Court Justices. Host Richard Brookhiser, author of John Marshall: The Man Who Made the Supreme Court, leads this journey across America to explore how one man’s principles shaped the Court — and how they continue to resonate today.
The Filmmakers
Thomas D. Lehrman, Executive Producer
Thomas D. Lehrman is co-founder and Managing Partner of Teamworthy Ventures, a venture investment firm with offices in Nashville and Greenwich, CT. Mr. Lehrman is co-founder and former Co-Chief Executive Officer of Gerson Lehrman Group (GLG), a research and information services company, and has been involved as a seed investor in numerous early-stage ventures. Mr. Lehrman currently serves on several company boards, including those of Ibotta (NYSE) and GLG.
Mr. Lehrman previously served as Director of the Office of WMD Terrorism in the U.S. Department of State, where he earned the Department’s Meritorious Honor Award, and as a member of the professional staff on the President’s WMD Commission. Earlier in his career, he worked as a financial analyst at Tiger Management. Mr. Lehrman has served as a Visiting Lecturer in Law at Yale Law School and as a Board Member of various K-12 and higher educational institutions including KIPP NYC Public Charter Schools, Achievement First Charter Schools, Brooklyn Excelsior Charter School, The Brunswick School, Sacred Heart Greenwich, The Buckley School, The Montfort Academy, The Gilder Lehrman Institute for American History, and Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory. Mr. Lehrman is also a member of the Council on Foreign Relations, an Advisor to the James Madison Program at Princeton University, served on the Board of the Becket Fund for Religious Liberty, and is Executive Producer of Free Exercise: America’s Story of Religious Liberty.
Mr. Lehrman graduated with a B.A. from Duke University and a J.D. from Yale Law School and his writings have appeared in the Wall Street Journal, New York Times, and various law and policy journals. He lives with his wife, Mara, and three of their five children in Nashville, Tennessee.
Evan A. Young, Executive Producer
Justice Evan A. Young was appointed to the Supreme Court of Texas in November 2021 by Governor Greg Abbott. Justice Young subsequently was elected in November 2022 to a term that expires December 31, 2028.
Justice Young clerked for U.S. Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia and served as Counsel to the Attorney General at the U.S. Department of Justice, during which time he spent nearly a year based at the U.S. Embassy in Baghdad, Iraq, helping lead the U.S. Government’s Rule of Law mission.
He joined the law firm Baker Botts L.L.P. and served as chair of the firm’s Supreme Court and Constitutional Law practice group. Justice Young, who served as a member of the Texas Judicial Council from 2017 until his appointment to the Supreme Court, is a former chair of the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children Texas Regional Office, a member of the Supreme Court Advisory Committee, an elected member of the American Law Institute, and an adjunct professor at The University of Texas School of Law.
Justice Young received Bachelor of Arts degrees from Duke University and from Oxford University, where he was a British Marshall Scholar, and his law degree from Yale Law School. He is a graduate of Tom C. Clark High School in San Antonio and now resides in Austin with his wife, Tobi, and their daughter.
Richard Brookhiser, Host
For fifty years, historian and journalist Richard Brookhiser has covered everything from the Jamestown Colony to pandemics past and present. He is the biographer of George Washington, Alexander Hamilton, John Marshall, James Madison and Abraham Lincoln. Most recently, he was the author of “Glorious Lessons: John Trumbull, Painter of the American Revolution.” He is a senior editor of National Review and a columnist for American History. In 2008 he was awarded the National Medal for the Humanities. He was also the writer and host of the documentary, “Free Exercise: America’s Story of Religious Liberty.”
Leo Eaton, Director and Writer
Leo Eaton was an Emmy award-winning filmmaker who wrote, produced, directed and executive produced TV series and specials for U.S. and foreign broadcasters for more than three decades. Most recently, Eaton produced, directed the documentary “Free Exercise: America’s Story of Religious Liberty.” Previously, he executive produced the PBS/BBC 6-part series Story of China and wrote and directed the PBS special Weekend in Havana (all these projects incorporate the ‘history in the present’ narrative style). Other notable work for PBS includes Arts & the Mind, Homeland: Immigration in America and In Search of Ancient Ireland. Eaton produced National Geographic Channel’s Emmy® award-winning Can the Gulf Survive about the BP oil spill, executive produced The Story of India for PBS & BBC-TV, produced PBS’s groundbreaking 21-hour series America at a Crossroads, and co-created the Canadian/US Emmy® award-winning children’s series Zoboomafoo among many other works. Eaton passed away in March 2022.
John Paulson, Producer
John Paulson is a veteran creator of documentaries, biographies, and performing arts specials, many of them for public television. Currently he is completing a film on Virgil Thomson, a composer who ranks alongside Copland and Bernstein as a 20th Century master and who more than anyone else originated the American sound in classical music. Paulson produced the television specials, Mister Rogers: It’s You I Like, a Primetime Emmy Award nominee, What the World Needs Now: Words by Hal David, and JFK: The Lost Inaugural Gala, featuring long-lost footage from the 1961 pre-inaugural concert. He also directed A Raisin in the Sun Revisited, celebrating the legacy of Lorraine Hansberry, and the classical concert program, HOMECOMING: The Kansas City Symphony & Joyce DiDonato. Paulson’s critically acclaimed American Masters biography, Les Paul Chasing Sound, in addition to its Primetime Emmy nomination, also received the ASCAP Deems Taylor Award. Paulson spent more than a decade with the Smithsonian Institution where he produced award-winning media for museum exhibition and television broadcast. Among his work was the acclaimed film, Woody Guthrie Legacy, and a trio of programs celebrating the 300th anniversary of the invention of the piano: the concert special Piano Grand!, the documentary People and Pianos: 300 Years, and the exhibit film Piano 300. His programs for Maryland Public Television capturing the diverse landscapes and cultures of the Chesapeake Bay region have earned eleven Emmy Awards (NCCB). Paulson is a member of the Director’s Guild of America, and teaches Filmmaking for Public Television in the graduate School of Communication, American University, Washington, D.C.
Barbara Ballow, Editor
Barbara Ballow is an award-winning DC-based editor who has been telling compelling stories for more than three decades. Ballow has cut many of Leo Eaton’s documentaries, including Free Exercise: America’s Story of Religious Liberty, Weekend in Havana, Sacred Journeys, Arts & the Mind, In Search of Ancient Ireland and Emmy® award-winning Can the Gulf Survive. Ballow’s work includes programs for Frontline and America at a Crossroads for PBS, Autism is a World for CNN (nominated for an Academy Award), multiple specials and series for National Geographic Channel, and also The Kennedy Center Honors, for which she also won an Emmy.
credits
Directed by
Produced by
BARBARA BALLOW
LEO EATON
LYN RAPPAPORT REID
JOHN PAULSON
Presented by
RICHARD BROOKHISER
Written by
RICHARD BROOKHISER
LEO EATON
From the book
John Marshall,
the Man Who Made the Supreme Court
By Richard Brookhiser
Executive Producers
THOMAS D. LEHRMAN
EVAN A. YOUNG
Director of Photography
GARY KEITH GRIFFIN
Editor
BARBARA BALLOW
Music Composed & Conducted by
Musician Soloists
DANIEL EDWARDS – Oboe
SUSANNA KLEIN – Violin
ALI FOLEY SHENK – Flute
BRIAN STRAWLEY – Trumpet
Original Music © 2020, John Keltonic, JDK Music, ASCAP, Used By Permission
Principal Audio
MATT BLACKERBY
Additional Directors of Photography
PETR CIKHART
WESLEY HUNT
SAM SHINN
Archival Producers
SUSAN HORMUTH
ALISON RICHARDS
Additional Camera
STUART PENNY
Additional Audio
CHRIS BROHOLM
GEORGE INGMIRE
Assistant Editors
J. CONNOR BUCKLEY
SERGE DELPIERRE
BECCA SCHWARTZ
GRAPHIC ART & ANIMATION
STACY JANNIS
Jannis Productions, Inc.
&
JOHN CRANMER
Maya Vision International (UK)
Post Production Audio Services
HURLEY’S SOUND
Special Artwork
ROBERT G. RICHARDS JR.
Promotion Cover Artwork
CHRIS HOPKINS
Website
Drone Aerial Photography
JEREMY JONES (603 Drones LLC)
COREY LONGSTRETH (Stretch Video)
RICHARD MACDONAL (New Media Systems Inc.)
Assistant to Mr. Thomas Lehrman
MELANIE ASHMORE
TALIA FURCHAK
Aaron Burr Trial Coordination
RACHEL C. BALLOW
Dartmouth College Production Assistant
SOPHIA WUGANG
Casting
ARVOLD CASTING, Atlanta, GA
Featuring
BRIAN K. LANDIS as John Marshall
RICHARD ‘FRITZ’ KLEIN as Abraham Lincoln
Studio Wardrobe
YOSHIE LEWIS
Green Screen Studio
INTERFACE MEDIA GROUP
Studio Gaffer
MICHAEL YODER
Studio Grip
MICHAEL WILSON
Studio Chyron
ANGELA ADKINS
Studio Hair/Make Up
KIM REYES
Post Production Video Services
HENNINGER MEDIA SERVICES
LAURA HARRELL – Project Manager
JEF HUEY – Sr. Editor
DAVE MARKUN – Sr. Colorist
ERIC STENMARK – Editor
LAURA VON SCHRILTZ – Sales Director
Narration Recording
K-Town Studios, Kingston, NY
CARL SHILLITO – Engineer
SONIC UNION, NY
DRC STUDIO, IL
Post Production Audio Services
HURLEY’S SOUND – DAVID HURLEY
Production Accountant
Hull Family Accountants, Westminster, MD
TERRI EBAUGH – Accountant
KIM DUVALL – Bookkeeper
MITCHELL REISS, President & CEO
COLONIAL WILLIAMSBURG is a registered trademark of
The Colonial Williamsburg Foundation.
Special Thanks to
Lewis and Louise Lehrman
Mara Grace Lehrman
The United States Coast Guard
USCGC EAGLE
USCG Station Tybee Island, GA
USCG Motion Picture and Television Office
Supreme Court of the United States
Public Information Office
KATHY ARBERG
TYLER LOPEZ
Thomas Jefferson Foundation at Monticello
Charlottesville, Virginia
JENNIFER A. LYON
The John Marshall House,
Richmond, VA, Owned by Preservation Virginia
Filming in the Old Supreme Court Chamber, US Capitol, Courtesy of US Senate Commission on Art
Office of Senate Curator
RICHARD DOERNER
SCOTT STRONG
Additional Special Thanks
Cherokee Nation, Tahlequah, OK
JULIE HUBBARD
Dartmouth College, Hanover, NH
ROBERT E. BONNER
Café Amelie, New Orleans, LA
The Federal Reserve System, Washington DC
ERIC KOLLIG
Gadsby’s Tavern Museum, Alexandria, VA
LIZ WILLIAMS
Gilder Lehrman Institute of
American History, New York, NY
SANDRA TRENHOLM
James River Bateau Festival, VA
National Constitution Center, Philadelphia, PA
BEN ROEBUCK
Oak Hill, Delaplane, VA
CHUCK CHAMBERLAIN
Owens-Thomas House and Slave Quarters,
Savannah, GA
SHANNON BROWNING-MULLIS
Precarious Beer Hall, Williamsburg, VA
ANDREW VOSS
Preservation Virginia, Richmond, VA
ELIZABETH S. KOSTELNY
JENNIFER HURST-WENDER
ROMAN MARTINEZ
Steamboat Natchez (New Orleans)
CAPT. CLARKE C. (DOC) HAWLEY
Virginia State Capitol, Richmond, VA
ELIZABETH MANCANO
JAY BRAXTON
ALEX TIMBERLAKE
The College of William & Mary, Williamsburg, VA
SUZANNE CLAVET
GERALD ‘JAY’ GAIDMORE
Yale Law School, New Haven, CT
JANET CONROY
ALDEN FERRO
A PRODUCTION OF
PRESENTED BY
PEREGRINE INSTITUTE
© 2025 Peregrine Institute LLC